Most people who hire a lawyer start with a name from someone they trust, and more than half also look on their own. In Clio’s 2019 Legal Trends Report, 59% of consumers asked someone they knew for a referral, 57% searched independently and 16% did both. A firm gets cases online by showing up in that independent search, by looking credible when a referred client checks its name, and by answering when either one calls.
The answering is where many firms lose. In 2024 Clio hired a research company to contact 500 law firms as prospective clients. 48% of the firms could not be reached by phone, even after the shoppers left messages, and only 33% replied to email.
Where clients look for a lawyer
The 2019 figures split into three groups. Take out the 16% who did both, and about 43% relied only on a referral while about 41% searched only on their own.
Referred clients still go online. Most of them type your name or your firm’s name into Google to find a phone number, and the page they land on either confirms what their friend said or raises doubts. Three-star reviews, an old website and a Google Business Profile with the wrong hours can lose a case you were handed.
People searching on their own type something like “divorce lawyer near me” or “DUI attorney Fresno”. What they see on that first page decides which firms they call.
What a client sees when they search for a lawyer
A search for a practice area plus a city usually shows four kinds of results. Each one runs on different rules, so it helps to know which you are working on.
| Result | How you get there | What you pay |
|---|---|---|
| Local Services Ads | Pass Google’s license and identity checks, collect reviews, answer leads | A fee per lead (call or message), not per click |
| Map results | A complete Google Business Profile in the right category, reviews, and an office near the searcher | Nothing to Google; the cost is your time or an agency |
| Regular search results | Practice-area pages that answer what clients ask, plus links from other sites | Content and SEO work, usually over months |
| Legal directories | Claimed and completed profiles on legal directories | Justia and Avvo are free and ad-supported; FindLaw, LawInfo and Super Lawyers are paid |
Local Services Ads now carry a single Google Verified badge, which replaced the separate Screened and Guaranteed badges. Firms that had already finished Google’s verification received the new badge automatically, and it appears on your ad profile.
The map results depend heavily on reviews and on how complete your profile is. If calls from your profile are thin, our guide on getting more calls from Google My Business covers the settings that matter, and how to get Google reviews for your business covers asking without breaking Google’s rules.
Regular search results take longest. A page on “what happens at a first DUI hearing in [county]” can bring cases for years, but don’t expect it to rank in its first month. Our piece on what 12 to 24 months of steady SEO gets you explains why the timeline looks the way it does.
Answering the phone decides who gets the case
Ranking first is wasted if nobody picks up. Clio’s 2024 secret shoppers reached just 52% of the firms they phoned, and only 40% answered the call. When shoppers did get through, 41% of firms gave rate information, 12% could estimate the total cost and 36% could explain the process and next steps.
Email was worse. Only 18% of email replies covered next steps or expected costs. Afterward, 73% of shoppers who reached a firm said they were unlikely to recommend it.
When a client calls three firms and only one answers, that firm gets the first real conversation. A missed call usually means the client moves to the next name on the list. Most of this can be fixed without new marketing spend:
- Have a person answer during business hours, and use an answering service or intake line after hours.
- Return every message the same day, by phone and by text if the client allows it.
- Give intake staff a short script: how fees work, what the first meeting costs, what happens next and when.
- Track calls from your website, profile and ads separately so you can see which ones go unanswered.
What your website has to answer
Clio’s shoppers also looked at firm websites before reaching out. Only 30% could easily understand the process of hiring the firm, and 14% could find pricing information.
A practice-area page that wins cases answers the questions a nervous client has at 10 p.m.: how you charge (flat fee, hourly or contingency), whether the first consultation is free, who they will talk to, and what happens in the first week. You can explain how fees work without quoting a final number. Check your state’s advertising rules on fee statements before you publish exact figures.
Building referrals without breaking Rule 7.2
Referrals are where 59% of clients start, but you can’t simply pay for them. ABA Model Rule 7.2(b) says a lawyer shall not give or promise anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer’s services. The model rule’s exceptions are narrow. You can pay the reasonable costs of permitted advertising and the usual charges of a legal service plan or a qualified lawyer referral service. You can also enter a reciprocal referral agreement with another lawyer or professional, as long as it isn’t exclusive and the client is told about it, and you can give nominal thank-you gifts that aren’t meant as payment.
Each state adopts its own version of the rule, so check yours with your state bar before you set up anything formal.
Within those limits, the referrals that keep coming usually come from two places. Past clients send friends when the case went well and the firm kept them informed. Other lawyers send cases they don’t handle to someone they trust to treat their client properly.
Find out where your signed cases come from
Ask every new client one question at intake: “How did you first hear about us?” Record the answer next to whether they signed. After a few months you will know your cost per signed case for each source, which is a better guide than leads or clicks.
Add call tracking to your website, Google Business Profile and ads so the numbers don’t depend on memory. Then put your effort where signed cases come from, and fix response times before you raise the budget. The general advice in our online marketing tips for service businesses applies to law firms too.
Common questions about how law firms get clients
How do most law firms get clients?
From referrals and from clients who search on their own. Many clients do both: they get a name from a friend, then look the firm up before calling.
Do people use Google to find a lawyer?
Yes. Clients who search on their own usually start with Google, and referred clients often look up the firm’s name before they call. Your Google Business Profile, reviews and website are part of both paths.
Are Google Local Services Ads worth it for law firms?
They charge per lead rather than per click and show the Google Verified badge, which suits firms that can answer every call quickly. Judge them by cost per signed case, not cost per lead.
Can lawyers pay for client referrals?
Not in general. Under ABA Model Rule 7.2(b), lawyers can’t give anything of value for a recommendation, apart from listed exceptions such as advertising costs, qualified lawyer referral services and nominal gifts. State versions of the rule differ.
What should a law firm’s website show to win more clients?
How you charge, whether the first consultation is free, who the client will speak with and what happens after they call. Put those answers on each practice-area page, where clients read before they call.
If you want more cases from search and from your Google profile, see how we handle law firm marketing and SEO.





